Updated as of June 2026
Carnelian vs Agate
| Carnelian | Agate | |
|---|---|---|
| Price / carat | $3 to $40 | $2 to $30 |
| Hardness (Mohs) | 6.75 | 6.75 |
| Color | Orange, Red, Brown | Multicolor, Gray, Blue, Brown, White |
| Treatment | Heat treatment | Dyeing (very common) |
The bottom line
Carnelian and Agate both make beautiful jewelry. Choose by the look you want first, then weigh hardness against how hard you will wear the piece, and let price settle close calls. Read the full guides for Carnelian and Agate.
Frequently asked questions
Is Carnelian or Agate more durable?
Both rate Mohs 6.75, so they are comparably durable.
Which is cheaper, Carnelian or Agate?
Carnelian runs about $3 to $40 per carat and Agate about $2 to $30 per carat, so Agate is usually the more affordable choice.
Which should I choose?
Pick Carnelian if you want orange tones and Agate if you prefer multicolor. Match the stone hardness to how you will wear it and let budget break the tie.